Tone policing is a phenomenon that occurs when a person attempts to control the emotional expression of another individual during a conversation or debate. It involves focusing on the way in which a person expresses themselves, rather than the content of their argument. This can be done in a variety of ways, such as dismissing someone's argument because they are too angry or too emotional, or telling someone to calm down or be more polite when they are expressing their views passionately. Tone policing can be particularly harmful in situations where marginalized groups are speaking out against oppression or discrimination. In these cases, tone policing can be used as a tool to silence these voices and maintain the status quo. It is important to recognize that tone policing is not about promoting civil discourse, but rather about controlling the conversation and maintaining power dynamics. It is also worth noting that tone policing can be a subtle form of gaslighting, as it can make the person being policed feel as though their emotions and experiences are not valid or important. This can be particularly damaging in situations where someone is already feeling marginalized or oppressed. Overall, it is important to recognize tone policing as a harmful behavior that can be used to silence marginalized voices and maintain power dynamics. Instead, we should focus on engaging with the content of someone's argument, regardless of how they choose to express themselves emotionally.
cognitive bias, logical fallacy, emotional expression, marginalized groups, oppression, gaslighting, power dynamics
Tone Policing is when someone tries to control a conversation or a discussion by telling other people how they should be expressing their thoughts and feelings. It is a form of cognitive bias, which means it is a way of thinking that can lead to wrong conclusions. It is also a type of logical fallacy, which means it is an argument that is not based on facts or true ideas. An 8 year old might say that Tone Policing is when someone tries to tell them how they should say something, even when they already said it in a nice way.
Tone Policing, Conversation Control, Argumentative Fallacy.
Tone policing is a cognitive bias and logical fallacy that involves the selective interpretation of an individual's words or tone in order to discredit their argument without engaging with the content of their statement. It is based on the false assumption that the way an individual expresses themselves has any bearing on the validity of the points they are making. Tone policing is often used as a tool to silence people and to prevent them from being heard. It is an insidious form of censorship which is used to undermine the legitimacy of certain voices, such as those from minority groups, and to maintain the status quo.
Tone-policing, cognitive biases, logical fallacies, discourse, silencing, censorship, legitimacy, minority groups, status quo.
We have 216.475 Topics and 472.432 Entries and Tone Policing has 3 entries on Design+Encyclopedia. Design+Encyclopedia is a free encyclopedia, written collaboratively by designers, creators, artists, innovators and architects. Become a contributor and expand our knowledge on Tone Policing today.